The league winning 1996/7 season saw the Magic Wolves pip both Archangel and Ajax Skerries to land the Serie A title with one game left despite a terrible end to the campaign with the team losing their final 3 games. Hopes that the Serie A triumph would herald in an new era of success failed to materialise with the team continuing their poor end to the previous season in the next. The reigning champions finished the 1997/8 season one place above the drop.

Despite high profile signings, the Eternal City's league performances over the following years were nothing to shout about with the club finishing well clear of the title contenders each season. The 2000/1 campaign was however a new low when the side finished 4th from bottom and were relegated. It later emerged that the Eternal City had bribed Boca Libertas to throw a game but despite this it was too little to save the team from Serie B.

The club had to face only one season in Serie B when promotion was achieved in 2002. The team has finished in mid-table mediocrity for most of the subsequent seasons. The 2009/10 season however saw the club claim 3rd place, their highest finish in 13 years and earned the side a place in the lucrative Panterra Super 16.

Club bites
- The Eternal City are Castleland's largest club.